Because everyone loves a good story

“It was a dark and stormy night.” That classic ghost story opening works perfectly for a whole genre of literature called the Gothic novel. You’ve probably encountered Gothic novels before, even if you didn’t realize that’s what they were. Once you know their characteristics, you’ll see how easy they are to spot.
They usually include creepy settings, exaggerated emotions, diabolical men and powerless women, feelings of suspense and mystery, disturbing visions or dreams, and the spooky supernatural. I’ve read a small handful, and they’re all over the “enjoyability” spectrum. Even though it’s not “spooky season” anymore, I think Gothic novels are always a good idea. Let me discuss a few with you, and you can decide what you think of the Gothic novel.
In college, I discovered that Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte was one of my favorite books. I read it and re-read it countless times. Something appealed to me about the desolate atmosphere, frail Jane’s moral fiber, and Rochester’s humbling. It’s set in an old mansion, something foreboding is always laughing in the attic, it feels cold and wind-swept, there are dreams and visions that foreshadow the future, and at first glance the domineering man seems likely to overpower the frail woman. Very Gothic.
But on closer inspection, I would consider Jane Eyre a Gothic novel with a twist. Rather than depicting a screaming, helpless woman, Charlotte Bronte gives Jane some grit. For example, although Jane is weak physically (she’s often compared to a fairy or a bird), she has the strength of character to resist temptation and defend herself against Rochester’s intimidation and schemes. Everyone’s emotions are still high-strung, including Jane’s for Rochester, but she keeps hers in check, allowing reason to rule passion. I think the resolution is satisfying, too. Overall, this is one of my favorite Gothic novels.
Wuthering Heights was written by Emily Bronte, Charlotte’s sister. Apparently that’s not enough to make it a good book. Instead, it’s like Emily took all the violent, unlikely, depressing, and claustrophobic parts of Jane Eyre and magnified them—without any of the redeeming qualities. On a desolate moor, an adopted gypsy boy named Heathcliff becomes the tyrannical master of the house, regularly abusing everyone nearly to death because he’s bitter he couldn’t marry his childhood friend, Catherine. After her death, he wants to be haunted by her ghost and finally gets his wish. He dies haunted and happy. It’s definitely Gothic, but I hated it.
Almost every character is awful. I couldn’t care about Catherine because she was selfish, stubborn, and mean. I despised Heathcliff, whose abuse and anger were wholly unjustified and deserved punishment, not reward. There are two other violent men who are more like rabid dogs than humans, and the women are unable to get justice or protection for themselves. Bronte tries to redeem a few characters at the end, but I couldn’t care about it. It felt too improbable and too late—their redemption couldn’t compensate for my dislike of them or the book. People who see this as a romantic story must have a dent in their moral compass. I think it’s a miserable waste of time.

We’ve seen a good mostly-Gothic novel, a miserable excuse for a Gothic novel, and now we’ll look at an excellent example: Dracula by Bram Stoker. Granted, it’s not a perfect book. It can be a bit slow-moving, the narration style feels stilted, and it takes the characters forever to realize there’s a vampire in their midst. But otherwise, it’s the Gothic novel at its finest. It begins in an ancient castle in Transylvania surrounded by howling wolves and whipping wind, and it continues to slowly build suspense till you’re nearly crawling out of your skin. Some of the descriptions have stuck with me for years.
Lucy, a lovely but helpless lady, slowly succumbs to Dracula’s continual attacks. Several men try to help her, but they’re always a few steps behind Dracula. The friends succeed in the end, but not everyone survives to see the other side. What makes this an interesting Gothic novel is that, rather than wallowing in or glorifying the darkness, it fights dark with light and evil with good. Despite the epistolary mode of storytelling, it still manages to keep you hooked with good old-fashioned suspense. Personally, it’s the best Gothic novel I’ve read.
There are so many other books in the Gothic category—good, bad, and even satirical. For example, you’d probably enjoy Jane Austen’s Northanger Abbey for its playful mockery of Gothic novels and the people who take them too seriously. I thought it was a hoot. Feel free to drop me a comment to let me know which Gothic novel is your favorite. And don’t forget to stay away from creepy castles, haunted attics, and especially vampires.

I much prefer Jayne Eyre to Wuthering, too. Bram offers the creeps, though carries religious superstition. In Vampire Count (which covers the count in his Sumerian days down to his death) I have vampires diarising the hunters as a crassly superstitious lot. Northanger is good, too, and I went back to Catherine’s source. You might enjoy some of my vampire books. If so, please let me know. I almost have a rewrite of Bunyan’s The Holy War, ready for publication.
https://archive.org/details/@vinyam777/lists/2/shakesvamps
Steve H Hakes